Logo

Agile vs. Prince2 - What's the difference and which is better for project management?

September 22, 2021

Agile vs. Prince2 - What's the difference and which is better for project management?

Project management methodologies are fundamental frameworks used to manage projects effectively. While there are several methodologies in existence, Agile and Prince2 are two of the most popular. The question of which is better is a common one. Let's delve into what each entails.

Agile Methodology

Agile is a project management methodology that emphasizes flexibility, collaboration, and delivering working software frequently. This methodology works by breaking down a project into smaller-incremental cycles called sprints, and each cycle produces tangible deliverables. Agile methodology provides room for constant changes to adapt to the dynamic nature of the project.

Agile methodology benefits include increased customer satisfaction, cost-effectiveness, reduced risks, continuous improvement, increased team morale, and faster product delivery.

Prince2 Methodology

Prince2, (Projects in Controlled Environments) is a project management methodology focused on controlling a project's costs, risks, and timelines. This methodology provides a controlled business environment for project planning, monitoring, and control. Prince2 methodology is a structured approach that divides a project into stages, with each stage meeting prerequisites before moving to the next.

Prince2 methodology benefits include proper resource allocation, early detection of problems, increased financial control, proactive risk management, and project governance.

Agile vs. Prince2

Agile and Prince2 differ regarding project objectives, project scope, the team's control level, and the project's method of approach.

Project Objectives

Agile projects are based on evolving project requirements, with the main objective of satisfying the customer. In contrast, Prince2 projects have predefined objectives which align with the organization's goals.

Project Scope

Agile projects tend to start small and expand gradually, while Prince2 projects are well-planned before the commencement date.

Team Control Level

Agile methodology empowers the team with high autonomy and flexibility, while Prince2 methodology is more hierarchical, with the project manager responsible for decision-making.

Method of Approach

Agile methodology is more adaptive, while Prince2 methodology follows a more prescriptive approach.

Which is Better?

The answer to this question depends on the project's scope, project stakeholders, and the prevailing business environment. Agile methodology is an excellent choice for projects with evolving stakeholder requirements, while Prince2 is the right fit for projects with predefined objectives.

It’s worth noting that both methodologies can be combined to cover their shortcomings. Agile methodology can help to bring flexibility to a Prince2 project, while the Prince2 methodology can provide structure and accountability for an agile project.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the effectiveness of a project management methodology is determined by its match to the project's needs. Agile methodology is suited for projects characterized by evolving requirements and increased customer satisfaction, while Prince2 methodology is suited for projects requiring a more structured and well-defined approach.

References

© 2023 Flare Compare